Koala Novels

Chapter 5

Letters on the Merritt

The Sheridan crisis moved faster than I expected.

Day three: hotel suppliers in three boroughs put Sheridan Holdings on COD. Day four: First Manhattan dropped its line. Day five: Star-Source Trust, of all places, issued a one-paragraph release confirming it would not extend the bridge. Pace's name was on the bottom of that release as Chairman, and I read it on my phone in the elevator on the way out of the morning meeting. He had not, in the end, fought his own grandmother on it.

Day six, Honor Ashworth summoned me in person.

I went.

Not as a courtesy. To see how the architect explained herself when the foundation was loose.

The Ashworth Greenwich estate was a hundred and forty acres off Round Hill Road, the kind of property whose front gate has its own staff. The library was three rooms of leather and a Helen Frankenthaler over the mantel. Honor Ashworth was in the wing chair by the fireplace, in pearls and a navy boatneck, white hair set with the kind of precision you can only get at home with a regular Tuesday person.

She didn't lift her eyes when I came in.

"Miss Thorne. That's quite an arrival."

I sat.

"Mrs. Ashworth. That's quite an old playbook."

Her face went cold. The housekeeper, who had been pouring tea, made a small offended sound.

"Manners."

Driscoll, at my shoulder: "Watch how you speak to the heir of the Thorne estate."

The housekeeper closed her mouth.

Honor Ashworth let me sit there for a beat, looking me over.

"You're sharper than I imagined a Sheridan would be."

"Then you should have left a Sheridan in my crib."

The fire crackled.

She set her teacup down on the side table with deliberate ceremony.

"I brought Cherry-Anne back because the Sheridans needed a real daughter and Pace needed a manageable one. You were too sharp for him. Too sharp for that house. Marriages do not survive a wife who is sharper than her husband, Miss Thorne. Old families don't survive on women like you."

I let her see my face.

"And the Ashworths' survival has been built on women being smaller."

She struck the chair arm with her palm.

"Beatrice Thorne. Don't think being a Thorne is going to keep you. Your mother was a Thorne too. It didn't save her."

The fire took a long single second.

Driscoll's color changed.

I held very still.

"My mother died of what."

Honor Ashworth's mouth moved once, half a syllable, before she caught it. She had spent fifty years being good at this. The miss was small.

"That isn't what I meant."

I stood up.

"Thank you."

She frowned.

"For what."

I lifted my phone from where I had set it on the side table next to her tea. Face up. Voice Memos open. The small red dot pulsing.

"For confirming the Ashworths had a hand in 2002."

She went the color of paper.

From the doorway behind us a sound. Pace, in the dark suit he had worn home from Cinder Lake the day before. He had been there long enough.

He came in three steps and didn't take his eyes off his grandmother.

"Grandmother. My mother's car. On the Merritt. Was that part of this, too?"

Honor Ashworth's face tore for a quarter-second. I caught it.

Pace's mother, Eleanor Ashworth, had been a Thorne by blood. A first cousin once removed of Cabot's, on the Boston side. A friend of my mother's, before either of us was born.

She had died on December 22, 2012, on the Merritt Parkway near the Round Hill Road exit. One-car, no skid marks, no other vehicle, 11:47 PM. A box of hospital records had been on the passenger seat, charred. The Thorne family lawyer at Ropes & Gray had been expecting her at his Boston office at 9 AM the morning after.

Pace had been thirteen.

He had been told for thirteen years that his mother fell asleep at the wheel coming home from a Christmas dinner.

His grandmother lifted her chin.

"Pace. Who let you in here."

"Answer me."

Honor Ashworth gripped the head of her walking stick.

"Your mother fell asleep at the wheel."

"And Claire's mother."

The old woman's voice rose for the first time.

"The Thornes' business is not yours."

Pace laughed once.

"So it's a Thorne business."

She came out of the wing chair in one motion, faster than a seventy-one-year-old should, and her hand was up.

I caught it.

The flat of her palm struck the inside of my wrist on its way to Pace's face. The sound was clean and loud in the library.

Pace's face went the second white of the week.

"Claire."

I drew my hand back. The bones of my wrist sang.

"Mrs. Ashworth. That'll be on the next filing as well."

She was shaking.

Driscoll stepped through the door with two men I had not seen before.

"Miss Thorne. Mr. Thorne is at the gate."

Three black cars in the drive. The middle window came down.

Cabot Thorne did not get out. He looked at his hands on the dash for a moment, then he looked at Honor Ashworth through her own library window across forty feet of gravel and the rear vestibule.

He didn't raise his voice. The window carried it.

"Honor. Twenty-two years. The Thornes are owed an account."

She braced one hand on the back of the wing chair.

"There is no account. You have no proof."

I held the phone out toward Driscoll. He passed it back through me to the man at the door. Driscoll, at the same time, set a banker's folder on the library's central table.

"Cayman wire confirmations from the Ashworth Family Foundation to a registered medical-research nonprofit shell, 2002 through 2005. The signatory of record was Mrs. Ashworth's private secretary. Both the secretary and her successor are deposed."

Pace put both his hands flat on the library table and breathed once.

He looked up at me. His eyes were wet.

"Claire — I didn't — "

I lifted my hand.

"There's a lot you didn't."

Outside, the men with Cabot Thorne had started moving toward the side entrance, two of them carrying empty banker's boxes. The library's archives were about to be sealed. Mrs. Ashworth's housekeeper had begun, very quietly, to cry.

Honor Ashworth straightened her spine.

"Beatrice Thorne. You may have my house. You won't have Pace once any of this is over."

I looked at her with no heat at all.

"From the second the cabernet hit my hem at the Whitney, Mrs. Ashworth, your grandson and I were over."

Pace had nothing in his face by then. He was just standing in the library, looking at his hands on the table.

The Ashworth filings went two days later.

Cinder Lake led a joint motion with three institutional partners requiring Star-Source Trust to disclose certain historical fund flows. The SEC's New York office sent a deputy associate director in person. The state AG's white-collar bureau attached. The stock didn't last the morning.

The day they took Honor Ashworth into the city for questioning, Pace came to the lobby of One Vanderbilt.

He didn't try to come up.

He stood on the sidewalk outside the revolving doors and waited.

It was raining, the kind of cold November rain New York gets right before Thanksgiving, gray on gray, with wet leaves on the curb. He didn't have an umbrella.

The front desk called up after the first hour. They called up after the third. They called up at the sixth.

"Miss Thorne. Mr. Ashworth is still on the sidewalk."

I was signing the asset-freeze motion against Sheridan Holdings. I finished the last page.

"Send him up."

He came through the door of the conference room with water still on his face. His coat was a darker color than it was supposed to be. His hair was flat against his skull. He set a manila envelope on the table.

"This is what I have."

I opened it.

Inside were two things. The first was the original New York State motor-vehicle accident report for Eleanor Ashworth, December 22, 2012, with a small clipped addendum from a state trooper noting no skid, no evasion, dry road, no measurable alcohol — referred to homicide, then refiled as routine. The second was a folded yellowed page on his mother's stationery.

Pace —

If you ever meet a Thorne daughter, do not harm her. I cannot explain now, but please.

— Mom

Pace's voice came out hoarse.

"My grandmother had it. Behind the Frankenthaler. I found it the morning they took her in."

I read it twice.

He sat down opposite me.

"Claire."

I closed the envelope.

"Pace."

He got up from the chair and went down on one knee on my office carpet.

It wasn't the proposing kind. It wasn't even close. It was the kind a man goes down to when he is begging not to be left alone with what he is.

"Claire. I'm sorry."

I looked at his wet shoulder.

Three years ago he had waited in the rain for me too. After a fight I'd had with Whit in the city, I had walked the East River alone for two hours with my coat misbuttoned, and Pace had found me at the rail at 78th Street, and he had taken off his coat and put it on me and said you don't have to be alone in this anymore.

I had loved him for it for a very long time.

I looked at him on my office carpet, in the wet coat, with his mother's letter on the table between us, and I felt nothing move in my chest at all.

"Pace. I accept the apology."

His head came up. There was something in his eyes I had to look away from.

I picked the envelope back up.

"I'm not taking you back."

The thing in his eyes went out.

"Claire — please — "

"You loved a Sheridan. When Cherry became the Sheridan, you went to her. When I became a Thorne, you came here. The math is the math."

His throat worked. "It isn't — "

"It doesn't matter whether it is or isn't."

I slid his mother's letter back across the table.

"Your mother asked you not to hurt a Thorne daughter. You did. You can live with that the rest of your life."

His eyes were red.

He went out without saying anything else. The conference-room door closed behind him slow.

From the window I watched him cross the lobby. His back was bent under the wet coat. He looked, for the first time since I had known him, smaller than the building he was standing in.

It looked like something that had been a long time arriving had finally landed on the right shoulders.

Take a break or keep reading. More stories whenever you want.